I have been thinking about the word agency lately.
It started with the game class I taught this summer at Peters Valley Craft School. When prepping for the class I read a thesis about the differences between table games and computer games. The gist was that table games are community oriented and all the players have the agency to make decisions about all aspects of the game. They can change rules, create new pieces, assign tasks, etc., whereas in computer games the path is somewhat set.
There is a democracy in table games, which I experienced in my class. We took turns introducing new games. We decided which rules we wanted to play. Each student liked different games but were good sports about playing all of them. The games were object oriented – markers, cards, boards, tokens. As makers, we had fun exploring these objects. A few students recreated games from their childhood, or made new pieces or fixed old ones, which were meaningful because it reminded them of their parents and grandparents. All these aspects of table gaming led participants down very personal paths, creating an easy flow of curiosity and creativity, while co-teacher Jules Crooks and I supported them as their technical assistants.
Later in the summer I taught a few turning classes. I usually introduce one technique at a time, which students practice until technical proficiency develops. I noticed how many students would come to me after multiple techniques were introduced and would say, now what do you want me to do? This did not happen as much 15 years ago. By the time I had introduced a technique I would hardly be able to stop students from going on to the next project. They were curious about, and had agency with, the unknown of what’s next.
Over the last year, I’ve seen more students working with AI to create their designs. There’s nothing wrong with using AI for design but it’s important to remember it’s just the beginning. Once you learn a skill on YouTube, or draft a design with AI, now personal expression and the discovery of the creative process comes in. An unexpected problem will arise and then you’ll have to make a choice about how to solve it, and then another one, and another one, until you decide your project is done. This is your agency as a maker.
While researching gaming I came across this quote, “Games are the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles.” In other words, a way to develop agency. Developing your agency, your capacity for action, even when you don’t know where you're going, will enhance your creativity. This is the path to improving your craft and developing your own personal expression.
This was published in the Studio newsletter. You can read more here.